At Least We’re Not France
For all you taxpayers out there who are planning to spend this weekend slaving over a last-minute return, and for all you business leaders fretting over President Obama’s corporate tax plans, here’s some cold comfort: It could be worse … and in many countries, it is.
Forbes has released its annual Tax Misery and Reform Index, which assembles data on the top rates for corporate and personal income tax, wealth tax, social security taxes, and VAT/sales taxes in more than 60 countries.
The United States is by no means a high-tax-misery country. With a misery score of 85.3, the U.S. ranks way down the list at 48th, well below several countries with famously mild corporate tax regimes, such as Luxembourg (ranked 27th) and Ireland (40th). Higher rates for personal income and social security in these nations more than offset their relatively low corporate income tax rates.
Still, there’s definitely cause for concern in the U.S. corporate income rate, at 35 percent, which is topped only by Japan (41 percent) and — surprise! — India (42 percent). And, of course, there’s state tax on top of that; if you’re foolish enough to operate a business in New York City, you’ll pay a combined maximum rate of 46.2 percent.
But before we get too irate about U.S. business taxes, let’s not forget the employer social security tax, a relatively benign 7.7 percent in the United States. Companies in Mexico can pay close to 39 percent, and in the Ukraine it’s a whopping 50 percent.
In unenviable first place atop the Misery List is France, which combines a corporate income tax similar to that of the United States with a 45 percent employer social security tax and high rates in just about every other category.
I’m reminded of the time a couple of years ago when a major British newspaper ran a competition to find a suitable national motto for the country. The best my sardonic compatriots could come up with was a bunch of quips like “Americans Who Missed the Boat” and “At Least We’re Not French.”
I’ll think about that as I work on my income taxes this weekend. At least we’re not France.
At least not yet. ###







April 8th, 2009 at 6:37 pm
Great content and I really liked the Misery Index chart as a healthy dose of reality.
Interesting to note that most of Western Europe /Nordic countries were at the top of the high tax - misery index. #1 France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, Finland, Sweden, Belgium. Aren’t these the ones cited as “best” practices in DC?
Just remember the words of Thomas Jefferson; “A wise and frugal government, which shall leave men free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned - this is the sum of good government.”
I have to go, to do my taxes too (before they go up).
April 10th, 2009 at 3:04 pm
Score one for the Sage of Monticello.
I wouldn’t be surprised if those european tax systems were sometimes held up as models in DC, though it’s hard to imagine why. There’s been talk in some quarters of instigating a VAT system for the US. Which would bring us one step closer to a european-style tax code. Vive la difference, I say.
Good luck with your tax return
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment:
Register Here or Log in Here.
Big Fat Finance Blogs
Advertisement
Recent Posts
Archives
Your Account
Archived Categories
Subscribe